Benchmark WA Industrial Relations Case Database

Constitutional corporation test

doctrinal FED constitutional_corporation branch: jurisdiction_constitutional

Synthesis · 818 tagged cases

818 tagged decisions (418 as primary). Of primary decisions, the most common outcome is '(unspecified)' (265, 63%).

Outcome distribution

Outcomen%
Resolved (unspecified) 265 63%
Against applicant dismissed_jurisdiction 75 18%
Against applicant dismissed 31 7%
For applicant granted 13 3%
Resolved partial 9 2%
Resolved other 9 2%
Resolved adjourned 6 1%
Resolved reserved 3 1%
For applicant direction_issued 3 1%
Against applicant order issued - application dismissed 1 0%
Resolved quashed 1 0%
Resolved declaration that respondent is not a... 1 0%
For applicant declared_jurisdiction 1 0%

By jurisdiction

Courtn
Fair Work Commission401
Single Commissioner (WAIRC)177
Industrial Magistrates Court48
Fair Work Commission (Full Bench)40
Federal Court of Australia34
High Court of Australia25
Federal Court (Full Court)18
Full Bench (WAIRC)18
Fair Work Australia (former)15
Industrial Appeal Court7
Federal Magistrates Court (former)6
Commission in Court Session (WAIRC)6
Fair Work Australia (Full Bench, former)5
Federal Circuit Court of Australia5
WA Court of Appeal4
?3
NSWIRComm2
SASC1
QSC1
IRCA1
WASAT1

Key articulated principles · 12

para 68 — from [2008] WASCA 254 WA Court of Appeal
A corporation may be a trading corporation even though trading is not its predominant activity, but trading must be a substantial and not merely peripheral activity.
para 68 — from [2008] WASCA 254 WA Court of Appeal
The term 'trading' extends beyond buying and selling to business activities carried on with a view to earning revenue and includes trade in services.
para 68 — from [2008] WASCA 254 WA Court of Appeal
The making of a profit is not an essential prerequisite to trade, but it is a usual concomitant.
para 68 — from [2008] WASCA 254 WA Court of Appeal
The ends which a corporation seeks to serve by trading are irrelevant to its description; the fact that trading activities are conducted in the public interest or for a public purpose will not necessarily exclude their characterisation as trade.
para 68 — from [2008] WASCA 254 WA Court of Appeal
Whether the trading activities of an incorporated body are sufficient to justify its categorisation as a trading corporation is a question of fact and degree.
para 68 — from [2008] WASCA 254 WA Court of Appeal
The current activities of the corporation, while an important criterion for determining its characterisation, are not the only criterion; regard must also be had to the intended purpose of the corporation.
para 68 — from [2008] WASCA 254 WA Court of Appeal
The commercial nature of an activity is an element in deciding whether the activity is in trade or trading.
para 74 — from [2008] WASCA 254 WA Court of Appeal
When assessing whether a corporation is a trading corporation, the court must consider all the factors together in a qualitative judgment: the organisation's purpose, its non-profit status, the nature of its funding, the absence of profit motive, the provision of services free or at below-cost, the degree of government control, and the altruistic character of the work. When these factors are taken together, activities lacking commercial character cannot be described as trade.
para 74 — from [2008] WASCA 254 WA Court of Appeal
The provision of large-scale legal and allied services for reward is ordinarily trading, and the fact that services are not done for profit is not determinative of character; however, when services are provided free of charge for altruistic purposes under a non-profit constitution requiring application only to altruistic objects, pursuant to a government agreement under which the organisation is reimbursed for most of its costs, the activities lack commercial character and resemble those of a government-run legal aid agency rather than trade.
para 54 — from [1979] HCA 6 High Court
A corporation formed within Australia satisfies the constitutional description 'trading corporation' in s51(xx.) if trading is a substantial corporate activity, assessed by current activities rather than purpose of incorporation; the corporation's actual activities determine its nature.
para 51 — from [1979] HCA 6 High Court
Constitutional provisions such as 'trading corporation' in s51(xx.) must be given generous rather than restrictive construction and are not ossified to classifications current in 1901; they must embrace all that falls within their natural meaning according to the circumstances of the time.
para 57 — from [1979] HCA 6 High Court
Trade for constitutional purposes is not confined to dealing in goods or commodities; the commercial nature of an activity is an element in deciding whether action is in trade or trading.

Leading cases · by citation count

CitationCourtRoleCited
[2008] WASCA 254 WA Court of Appeal primary 47
[1979] HCA 6 High Court primary 24
[2015] FCAFC 1 Federal Court — Full Court primary 16
[2006] HCA 52 High Court primary 16
[1982] HCA 72 High Court primary 13
[1978] FCA 50 Federal Court primary 13
[2012] WAIRC 32 WAIRC — Full Bench primary 7
[2009] WAIRC 668 WAIRC — Full Bench primary 7

All tagged cases · 200

CitationCourtRoleDateOutcomeCited
[2008] WASCA 254 WA Court of Appeal primary 2008-12-10 Against applicant 47
[1979] HCA 6 High Court primary 1979-01-01 Against applicant 24
[2015] FCAFC 1 Federal Court — Full Court primary 2015-01-08 Resolved 16
[2006] HCA 52 High Court primary 2006-11-14 Against applicant 16
[1982] HCA 72 High Court primary 1982-01-01 Against applicant 13
[1978] FCA 50 Federal Court primary 1978-01-01 Resolved 13
[2012] WAIRC 32 WAIRC — Full Bench primary 2012-01-24 Resolved 7
[2009] WAIRC 668 WAIRC — Full Bench primary 2009-01-01 Against applicant 7
[1988] FCA 170 Federal Court primary 1987-09-01 For applicant 7
[2008] WAIRC 1732 WAIRC — Full Bench primary 2008-12-17 Against applicant 6
[2019] FWCFB 3740 FWC — Full Bench primary 2019-07-05 For applicant 4
[2017] FWC 5974 FWC primary 2017-11-15 Against applicant 4
[2016] FWC 2190 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 4
[1996] HCA 56 High Court primary 1996-01-01 Resolved 4
[2017] WAIRC 272 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2017-05-16 Against applicant 3
[2015] FWC 7309 FWC primary 2015-11-13 For applicant 3
[2007] FCAFC 177 Federal Court — Full Court primary 2007-11-22 For applicant 3
[2007] NSWIRComm 189 NSWIRComm primary 2007-09-24 3
[1998] FCA 551 Federal Court primary 1998-05-20 Against applicant 3
[2024] FWC 1796 FWC primary 2024-07-09 Against applicant 2
[2016] WAIRC 73 WAIRC — Full Bench primary 2016-02-10 Against applicant 2
[2015] FWC 8231 FWC primary 2015-12-07 Resolved 2
[2015] FWC 4200 FWC primary 2015-06-24 Against applicant 2
[2013] WAIRC 725 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2013-08-16 Against applicant 2
[2013] FWC 3302 FWC primary 2013-06-14 Against applicant 2
[2011] FWA 1401 FWA (former) primary 2011-03-03 Against applicant 2
[2010] FWA 1589 FWA (former) primary 2010-02-25 Against applicant 2
[2009] FCA 58 Federal Court primary 2009-02-06 Resolved 2
[1990] HCA 2 High Court primary 1990-01-01 Against applicant 2
[2025] WAIRC 00382 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2025-07-29 Resolved 1
[2023] WAIRC 329 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2023-06-14 Resolved 1
[2023] WAIRC 100 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2023-02-20 Resolved 1
[2022] WAIRC 338 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2022-08-10 Resolved 1
[2020] WAIRC 938 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2020-12-02 Against applicant 1
[2018] FWC 7650 FWC primary 2018-12-18 Against applicant 1
[2017] WAIRC 968 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2017-11-29 Resolved 1
[2017] WAIRC 236 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2017-04-27 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 7886 FWC primary 2016-11-21 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 114 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 2395 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 3507 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 3574 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 4174 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 4426 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 4946 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2015] FWC 3639 FWC primary 2015-06-29 Against applicant 1
[2015] FWC 58 FWC primary 2015-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2014] FWC 6723 FWC primary 2014-09-30 Against applicant 1
[2014] FWC 4476 FWC primary 2014-07-07 Against applicant 1
[2012] WAIRC 1087 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2012-12-05 Against applicant 1
[2012] FWA 8524 FWA (former) primary 2012-10-12 Against applicant 1
[2011] WAIRC 344 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2011-05-19 Against applicant 1
[2009] WAIRC 666 WAIRC — Full Bench primary 2009-09-15 For applicant 1
[2007] NSWIRComm 159 NSWIRComm primary 2007-06-28 1
[2006] WAIRC 5849 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2006-01-01 Against applicant 1
[1991] FCA 154 Federal Court primary 1991-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2026] FWC 2609 FWC primary 2026-07-09 0
[2026] FWC 2566 FWC primary 2026-07-08 0
[2026] FWC 2561 FWC primary 2026-07-07 0
[2026] FWC 2562 FWC primary 2026-07-07 0
[2026] FWC 2476 FWC primary 2026-07-06 0
[2026] FWC 2014 FWC primary 2026-07-03 0
[2026] FWC 2460 FWC primary 2026-07-01 0
[2026] FWC 2356 FWC primary 2026-06-25 0
[2026] FWC 2343 FWC primary 2026-06-24 0
[2026] FWC 2282 FWC primary 2026-06-22 0
[2026] FWC 2255 FWC primary 2026-06-18 0
[2026] FWC 2148 FWC primary 2026-06-15 0
[2026] FWC 2189 FWC primary 2026-06-12 0
[2026] FWC 2074 FWC primary 2026-06-04 0
[2026] FWC 2012 FWC primary 2026-06-02 0
[2026] WAIRC 00257 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2026-04-28 For applicant 0
[2026] WAIRC 00196 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2026-04-02 Against applicant 0
2026 WAIRC 00127 WAIRC — Full Bench primary 2026-03-06 Against applicant 0
(2026) 106 WAIG WAIRC — Full Bench primary 2026-03-04 0
[2026] WAIRC 00117 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2026-03-03 Against applicant 0
[2026] WAIRC 00119 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2026-03-03 Against applicant 0
[2026] WAIRC 00035 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2026-01-23 Resolved 0
[2026] FWC 1633 FWC primary 2026-01-01 For applicant 0
[2026] FWC 454 FWC primary 2026-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2026] FWC 812 FWC primary 2026-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2026] FWC 46 FWC primary 2026-01-01 0
[2025] WAIRC 00990 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2025-12-15 Against applicant 0
(2025) 105 WAIG WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2025-11-06 0
2025 WAIRC 00859 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2025-10-15 Against applicant 0
[2025] WAIRC 00861 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2025-10-15 Against applicant 0
(2025) 105 WAIG WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2025-10-15 0
[2025] WAIRC 00707 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2025-08-15 Against applicant 0
[2025] FWCFB 165 FWC — Full Bench primary 2025-08-04 0
[2025] FWCFB 131 FWC — Full Bench primary 2025-07-01 0
[2025] FWC 1726 FWC primary 2025-06-19 Against applicant 0
[2025] WAIRC 00231 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2025-04-09 Resolved 0
2025 WAIRC 00150 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2025-03-07 Against applicant 0
(2025) 105 WAIG WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2025-03-07 0
(2025) 105 WAIG WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2025-02-20 0
[2025] WAIRC 00021 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2025-01-15 For applicant 0
(2025) 105 WAIG WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2025-01-15 0
[2025] HCA 25 High Court primary 2025-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2025] FWC 13 FWC primary 2025-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2025] FWC 1195 FWC primary 2025-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2025] FWC 1199 FWC primary 2025-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2025] FWC 1497 FWC primary 2025-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2025] FWC 1996 FWC primary 2025-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2025] FWC 2180 FWC primary 2025-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2025] FWC 3112 FWC primary 2025-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2025] FWC 3413 FWC primary 2025-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2025] FWC 3433 FWC primary 2025-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2025] FWC 556 FWC primary 2025-01-01 For applicant 0
[2025] FWC 2369 FWC primary 2025-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2025] FWC 2813 FWC primary 2025-01-01 For applicant 0
[2025] FWC 3603 FWC primary 2025-01-01 0
[2025] FWC 3609 FWC primary 2025-01-01 0
[2025] FWC 3613 FWC primary 2025-01-01 0
[2025] FWC 3620 FWC primary 2025-01-01 0
[2025] FWC 3622 FWC primary 2025-01-01 0
[2025] FWC 3644 FWC primary 2025-01-01 0
[2025] FWC 3647 FWC primary 2025-01-01 0
[2025] FWC 3649 FWC primary 2025-01-01 0
[2025] FWC 3652 FWC primary 2025-01-01 0
[2025] FWC 3893 FWC primary 2025-01-01 0
[2025] FWCFB 185 FWC — Full Bench primary 2025-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 2201 FWC primary 2024-09-19 Against applicant 0
(2024) 104 WAIG WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2024-07-02 0
(2025) 105 WAIG 20 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2024-06-21 0
[2024] WAIRC 330 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2024-06-14 Resolved 0
[2024] WAIRC 223 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2024-05-17 Against applicant 0
[2023] FWCFB 176 FWC — Full Bench primary 2024-04-29 0
[2024] WAIRC 157 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2024-04-15 Against applicant 0
(2024) 104 WAIG WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2024-04-03 0
[2024] FWC 29 FWC primary 2024-01-05 0
[2024] FWC 87 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 104 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 125 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 180 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 339 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 377 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 384 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 395 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 426 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 432 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 460 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 580 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 625 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 736 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 825 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 1020 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 1053 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 1185 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 1230 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 1312 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 1316 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 1351 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 1353 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 1442 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 1667 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 1884 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 2036 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 2226 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 2342 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 2345 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 2362 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 2370 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 2426 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 2491 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 2534 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 2608 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 2675 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 3123 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 3124 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 3205 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
[2024] FWC 3578 FWC primary 2024-01-01 0
(2023) 103 WAIG WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2023-10-24 0
(2024) 104 WAIG WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2023-09-27 0
[2023] FWCFB 162 FWC — Full Bench primary 2023-09-19 0
[2023] WAIRC 718 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2023-08-22 For applicant 0
[2023] WAIRC 691 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2023-08-15 Against applicant 0
[2023] WAIRC 386 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2023-07-17 Resolved 0
(2023) 103 WAIG WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2023-07-17 0
[2023] FWCFB 123 FWC — Full Bench primary 2023-07-12 0
[2023] WAIRC 346 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2023-06-28 Resolved 0
(2023) 103 WAIG 1 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2023-06-28 0
(2023) 103 WAIG WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2023-06-14 0
[2023] WAIRC 228 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2023-04-21 For applicant 0
[2023] FWC 305 FWC primary 2023-02-07 Against applicant 0
[2023] FWC 338 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0
[2023] FWC 363 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0
[2023] FWC 377 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0
[2023] FWC 391 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0
[2023] FWC 402 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0
[2023] FWC 455 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0
[2023] FWC 559 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0
[2023] FWC 636 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0
[2023] FWC 769 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0
[2023] FWC 988 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0
[2023] FWC 1092 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0
[2023] FWC 1289 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0
[2023] FWC 1515 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0
[2023] FWC 1757 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0
[2023] FWC 2055 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0
[2023] FWC 2112 FWC primary 2023-01-01 0