Benchmark WA Industrial Relations Case Database

Jurisdictional facts

doctrinal BOTH jurisdictional_facts branch: jurisdiction_constitutional

Synthesis · 1478 tagged cases

1478 tagged decisions (689 as primary). Of primary decisions, the most common outcome is 'dismissed_jurisdiction' (373, 54%).

Outcome distribution

Outcomen%
Against applicant dismissed_jurisdiction 373 54%
Against applicant dismissed 175 25%
For applicant granted 64 9%
Resolved other 32 5%
Resolved partial 25 4%
Resolved adjourned 11 2%
Resolved reserved 6 1%
For applicant upheld 1 0%
Resolved (unspecified) 1 0%
Resolved discontinued 1 0%

By jurisdiction

Courtn
Fair Work Commission994
Single Commissioner (WAIRC)188
Full Bench (WAIRC)35
Fair Work Australia (former)35
Federal Court of Australia28
Fair Work Commission (Full Bench)27
Industrial Appeal Court27
High Court of Australia24
Public Service Appeal Board (former)23
WA Court of Appeal21
Federal Court (Full Court)18
Industrial Magistrates Court13
Commission in Court Session (WAIRC)11
Fair Work Australia (Full Bench, former)9
WA Supreme Court5
Federal Magistrates Court (former)4
Australian Industrial Relations Commission (former)3
?3
NSWIRComm2
Federal Circuit Court of Australia2
AIRC Full Bench (former)1
Federal Circuit and Family Court (Div 2 General)1
NSWCA1
QSC1
SAIRComm1
IRCA1

Key articulated principles · 12

para 42 — from [2014] FWCFB 1070 FWC — Full Bench
Section 394(1) is a procedural provision identifying who may make an application, similar to provisions establishing standing, and does not go to the jurisdiction of the Commission to grant an unfair dismissal remedy.
para 13 — from [2014] FWCFB 1070 FWC — Full Bench
In considering whether to waive an irregularity under s.586(b) for premature filing, relevant factors include whether respondent has suffered prejudice, whether there is an arguable case on merits, whether significant injustice would flow from dismissal of the application, and whether requiring re-filing would cause inconvenience and cost.
para 36 — from [1979] HCA 6 High Court
Where jurisdiction of a federal court depends on a constitutional fact (such as whether a corporation is a trading corporation under s51(xx.)), and the statute provides for appeal to the High Court, the Federal Court is not deprived of jurisdiction to determine that constitutional question, and its decision is subject to review but not prohibition.
para 36 — from [1979] HCA 6 High Court
Where Parliament confers on a court jurisdiction that depends on constitutional legislative power, and creates a condition precedent to jurisdiction (such as the existence of a trading corporation), the court cannot conclusively determine that condition if doing so would exceed constitutional power; the High Court alone can conclusively determine constitutional facts.
para ? — from [1995] HCA 58 High Court
If an administrative tribunal falls into an error of law which causes it to identify a wrong issue, ask itself a wrong question, ignore relevant material, rely on irrelevant material or make an erroneous finding, and the tribunal's exercise of power is thereby affected, it exceeds its authority or powers and commits jurisdictional error
para 14 — from [2008] AIRCFB 1088 AIRCFB
Where questions of jurisdiction are involved, it is the facts which are relevant, not the parties' subjective beliefs or the reasonableness of their conduct.
para 10 — from [2008] AIRCFB 1088 AIRCFB
Where questions of jurisdiction are involved, it is the facts which are relevant, not the parties' subjective beliefs or the reasonableness of their conduct.
para 15 — from [2008] AIRCFB 1088 AIRCFB
In determining jurisdictional questions, the relevant facts are what matter, not the parties' subjective beliefs or the reasonableness of their conduct.
para 51 — from [2006] WASCA 49 WA Court of Appeal
An appeal under s 90(1)(b) cannot be made on the ground that there has been an error in the construction or interpretation of the Act where the Full Bench has merely applied law which it has correctly understood to the facts of an individual case. It is for the Full Bench to weigh the relevant facts in the light of applicable law, and such fact-finding does not enliven appellate jurisdiction.
para 96 — from [2018] FCAFC 77 Federal Court — Full Court
Compliance with s 180(5) is not a jurisdictional fact. The relevant jurisdictional fact is the Commission's satisfaction under s 188(a)(i) that the employer has complied with s 180(5). However, where a statute conditions exercise of power on formation of satisfaction, the satisfaction must be reached by a rational, reasonable and logical process, considering all relevant matters.
para 105 — from [2018] FCAFC 77 Federal Court — Full Court
The language of 'satisfaction' or 'opinion' in a statute is a device to ensure that matters identified as preconditions to the exercise of power are not jurisdictional facts, but facts which need only be established to the satisfaction of the decision-maker.
para 22 — from [2002] WASCA 191 WA Court of Appeal
Section 29(1) of the IR Act confers standing to refer an industrial matter to the Commission but does not confer jurisdiction or additional powers on the Commission, nor does it prescribe principles of law to be applied in determining the matter.

Leading cases · by citation count

CitationCourtRoleCited
[1964] HCA 69 High Court primary 63
[2008] WASCA 254 WA Court of Appeal primary 47
[2011] FCA 975 Federal Court primary 38
[2014] FWCFB 1070 FWC — Full Bench primary 27
[1979] HCA 6 High Court primary 24
[2007] FCA 388 Federal Court primary 22
[1995] HCA 58 High Court primary 22
[2018] FCAFC 77 Federal Court — Full Court primary 20

All tagged cases · 200

CitationCourtRoleDateOutcomeCited
[1964] HCA 69 High Court primary 1964-01-01 Against applicant 63
[2008] WASCA 254 WA Court of Appeal primary 2008-12-10 Against applicant 47
[2011] FCA 975 Federal Court primary 2011-08-25 Resolved 38
[2014] FWCFB 1070 FWC — Full Bench primary 2014-03-05 Resolved 27
[1979] HCA 6 High Court primary 1979-01-01 Against applicant 24
[2007] FCA 388 Federal Court primary 2007-01-01 For applicant 22
[1995] HCA 58 High Court primary 1994-11-16 For applicant 22
[2018] FCAFC 77 Federal Court — Full Court primary 2018-05-25 Against applicant 20
[2004] WASCA 312 WA Court of Appeal primary 2004-12-22 Resolved 13
[2003] FCAFC 252 Federal Court — Full Court primary 2003-11-13 For applicant 12
[2013] FWCFB 6321 FWC — Full Bench primary 2013-09-03 For applicant 11
[2010] HCA 1 High Court primary 2010-01-01 For applicant 10
[1991] HCA 33 High Court primary 1991-01-01 Resolved 10
[2022] WASC 306 WA Supreme Court primary 2022-09-14 Against applicant 9
[2001] HCA 30 High Court primary 2001-01-01 Resolved 9
[2016] FCAFC 160 Federal Court — Full Court primary 2016-11-29 Resolved 8
[1999] WASCA 71 WA Court of Appeal primary 1999-04-01 Against applicant 8
[2009] WAIRC 668 WAIRC — Full Bench primary 2009-01-01 Against applicant 7
[2006] HCA 50 High Court primary 2006-11-08 Against applicant 7
[2014] WASCA 186 WA Court of Appeal primary 2014-10-20 Against applicant 6
[2013] FWC 9804 FWC primary 2013-12-16 Resolved 6
[2012] FCAFC 65 Federal Court — Full Court primary 2012-05-10 Against applicant 6
[2022] FCA 1234 Federal Court primary 2022-01-01 Resolved 5
[2021] WASCA 76 WA Court of Appeal primary 2021-05-03 Resolved 5
[2014] FCA 759 Federal Court primary 2014-07-24 Against applicant 5
[2010] FWA 6503 FWA (former) primary 2010-08-24 Against applicant 5
[2010] FWA 28 FWA (former) primary 2010-01-07 Against applicant 5
[2020] WAIRC 188 PSAB (former) primary 2020-03-31 Against applicant 4
[2019] FWCFB 3740 FWC — Full Bench primary 2019-07-05 For applicant 4
[2017] FWC 5974 FWC primary 2017-11-15 Against applicant 4
[2016] FWC 300 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 4
[2015] WAIRC 875 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2015-09-16 Against applicant 4
[2013] FWC 235 FWC primary 2013-01-01 For applicant 4
[2012] FWA 7049 FWA (former) primary 2012-08-17 Against applicant 4
[2011] FCAFC 155 Federal Court — Full Court primary 2011-12-02 Against applicant 4
[2011] FCA 719 Federal Court primary 2011-06-24 Resolved 4
[2008] FCAFC 135 Federal Court — Full Court primary 2008-07-18 For applicant 4
[2008] FCAFC 26 Federal Court — Full Court primary 2008-01-01 Against applicant 4
[1998] FCA 1404 Federal Court primary 1998-01-01 For applicant 4
[1983] HCA 35 High Court primary 1983-10-11 For applicant 4
[2022] WAIRC 692 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2022-09-28 Against applicant 3
[2017] WAIRC 272 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2017-05-16 Against applicant 3
[2016] FWC 1323 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 3
[2014] WAIRC 34 WAIRC — Full Bench primary 2014-01-01 Against applicant 3
[2014] FWC 107 FWC primary 2014-01-01 Resolved 3
[2013] WAIRC 390 PSAB (former) primary 2013-07-03 Against applicant 3
[2013] FWC 668 FWC primary 2013-01-01 Resolved 3
[2012] FWA 2375 FWA (former) primary 2012-03-23 Against applicant 3
[2011] FWA 6853 FWA (former) primary 2011-10-05 Against applicant 3
[2010] FWA 4540 FWA (former) primary 2010-06-18 Against applicant 3
[2007] NSWIRComm 189 NSWIRComm primary 2007-09-24 3
[1991] HCA 11 High Court primary 1991-04-24 Against applicant 3
[2024] FWC 1796 FWC primary 2024-07-09 Against applicant 2
[2020] FWCFB 4373 FWC — Full Bench primary 2020-08-19 Against applicant 2
[2019] FWCFB 6430 FWC — Full Bench primary 2019-09-19 For applicant 2
[2018] WAIRC 679 Industrial Magistrates Court primary 2018-08-02 Against applicant 2
[2018] WAIRC 419 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2018-07-16 Resolved 2
[2017] FCA 1557 Federal Court primary 2017-01-01 Against applicant 2
[2016] FWC 677 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 2
[2016] FWC 551 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Resolved 2
[2016] FWC 586 FWC primary 2016-01-01 For applicant 2
[2016] FWC 1395 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 2
[2016] FWC 4427 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 2
[2016] FWC 4896 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Resolved 2
[2015] WAIRC 995 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2015-11-10 For applicant 2
[2015] FWC 4200 FWC primary 2015-06-24 Against applicant 2
[2015] WASCA 46 WA Court of Appeal primary 2015-03-11 Against applicant 2
[2013] FWC 3302 FWC primary 2013-06-14 Against applicant 2
[2013] FCA 139 Federal Court primary 2013-02-04 Against applicant 2
[2012] FWA 6806 FWA (former) primary 2012-08-10 For applicant 2
[2011] FWA 1401 FWA (former) primary 2011-03-03 Against applicant 2
[2010] FWA 5374 FWA (former) primary 2010-07-22 Against applicant 2
[2010] FWA 3534 FWA (former) primary 2010-05-04 Against applicant 2
[2010] FWA 1589 FWA (former) primary 2010-02-25 Against applicant 2
[2010] WAIRC 937 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2010-01-01 Against applicant 2
[2004] WASCA 176 WA Court of Appeal primary 2004-08-13 Against applicant 2
[2001] WASCA 233 WA Court of Appeal primary 2001-08-07 Against applicant 2
[2026] WAIRC 00071 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2026-02-06 Resolved 1
[2026] FCA 305 Federal Court primary 2026-01-01 Against applicant 1
2025 WAIRC 00881 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2025-10-27 Against applicant 1
[2024] WAIRC 277 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2024-05-08 Against applicant 1
[2024] WASCA 37 WA Court of Appeal primary 2024-04-17 Resolved 1
[2024] FWC 575 FWC primary 2024-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2023] WAIRC 883 PSAB (former) primary 2023-11-09 Against applicant 1
[2023] WAIRC 329 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2023-06-14 Resolved 1
[2023] WAIRC 100 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2023-02-20 Resolved 1
[2023] WAIRC 91 WAIRC — Court Session primary 2023-02-17 Resolved 1
[2022] WASC 401 WA Supreme Court primary 2022-12-01 Against applicant 1
[2022] WAIRC 741 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2022-10-20 Against applicant 1
[2021] WAIRC 631 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2021-12-14 Against applicant 1
[2021] WAIRC 141 PSAB (former) primary 2021-05-20 Against applicant 1
[2020] WAIRC 996 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2020-12-18 Against applicant 1
[2020] WAIRC 938 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2020-12-02 Against applicant 1
[2020] FCCA 1354 Federal Circuit Court primary 2020-05-29 Resolved 1
[2020] WAIRC 47 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2020-01-21 Resolved 1
[2019] WAIRC 157 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2019-03-26 Against applicant 1
[2019] WAIRC 36 PSAB (former) primary 2018-12-18 Against applicant 1
[2018] WAIRC 734 WAIRC — Full Bench primary 2018-09-10 Resolved 1
[2017] WAIRC 968 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2017-11-29 Resolved 1
[2017] WAIRC 737 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2017-08-18 Against applicant 1
[2017] WAIRC 250 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2017-05-04 For applicant 1
[2016] WAIRC 882 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2016-11-16 Against applicant 1
[2016] WAIRC 718 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2016-08-19 For applicant 1
[2016] WAIRC 715 WAIRC — Full Bench primary 2016-08-18 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 114 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 504 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 612 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Resolved 1
[2016] FWC 817 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 583 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 692 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 1116 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 1120 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 1234 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 1360 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 1429 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 1133 FWC primary 2016-01-01 For applicant 1
[2016] FWC 1689 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 1334 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 2037 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 2091 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 2139 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 1669 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 2395 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 2094 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 2660 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 2662 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 2866 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 3023 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 3035 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 3049 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 3056 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Resolved 1
[2016] FWC 3242 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 3170 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Resolved 1
[2016] FWC 3298 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Resolved 1
[2016] FWC 3367 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 3574 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 3525 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 4207 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 3816 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 4263 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Resolved 1
[2016] FWC 4426 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 4015 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Resolved 1
[2016] FWC 4622 FWC primary 2016-01-01 For applicant 1
[2016] FWC 4294 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 4897 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 4850 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 4596 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2016] FWC 4946 FWC primary 2016-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2015] FWC 3639 FWC primary 2015-06-29 Against applicant 1
[2015] FCAFC 23 Federal Court — Full Court primary 2015-03-05 For applicant 1
[2015] FWC 1116 FWC primary 2015-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2015] FWC 5 FWC primary 2015-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2015] FWC 192 FWC primary 2015-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2015] FWC 6 FWC primary 2015-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2015] FWC 245 FWC primary 2015-01-01 For applicant 1
[2015] FWC 193 FWC primary 2015-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2015] FWC 529 FWC primary 2015-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2015] FWC 555 FWC primary 2015-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2015] FWC 638 FWC primary 2015-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2015] FWC 966 FWC primary 2015-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2015] FWC 1021 FWC primary 2015-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2015] FWC 1032 FWC primary 2015-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2015] FWC 1337 FWC primary 2015-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2014] FWC 6723 FWC primary 2014-09-30 Against applicant 1
[2014] FCA 428 Federal Court primary 2014-05-02 For applicant 1
[2014] FWC 2 FWC primary 2014-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2014] FWC 26 FWC primary 2014-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2013] FWC 6700 FWC primary 2013-09-06 Against applicant 1
[2013] FWC 611 FWC primary 2013-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2013] FWC 54 FWC primary 2013-01-01 Resolved 1
[2013] FWC 1 FWC primary 2013-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2013] FWC 264 FWC primary 2013-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2013] FWC 702 FWC primary 2013-01-01 Resolved 1
[2012] FWA 9634 FWA (former) primary 2012-11-12 Against applicant 1
[2012] FWA 8776 FWA (former) primary 2012-10-17 For applicant 1
[2012] FWA 8524 FWA (former) primary 2012-10-12 Against applicant 1
[2012] WAIRC 381 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2012-06-21 Against applicant 1
[2012] FCAFC 86 Federal Court — Full Court primary 2012-05-21 Against applicant 1
[2010] FWA 7644 FWA (former) primary 2010-09-30 Resolved 1
[2010] FWAFB 7124 FWAFB primary 2010-09-17 Against applicant 1
[2010] FWA 7321 FWA (former) primary 2010-09-17 Against applicant 1
[2010] FWA 4626 FWA (former) primary 2010-07-05 Against applicant 1
[2010] WAIRC 1210 Industrial Magistrates Court primary 2010-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2008] AIRCFB 358 AIRCFB primary 2008-04-22 Against applicant 1
[2008] AIRC 340 AIRC (former) primary 2008-04-16 Against applicant 1
[2006] WAIRC 5849 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2006-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2004] WAIRC 11217 WAIRC — Full Bench primary 2004-01-01 Resolved 1
[2003] HCA 7 High Court primary 2003-01-01 Against applicant 1
[1993] HCA 81 High Court primary 1993-01-01 Against applicant 1
[2026] WAIRC 461 WAIRC — Full Bench primary 2026-07-03 Against applicant 0
2026 WAIRC 00185 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2026-03-27 Against applicant 0
2026 WAIRC 00187 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2026-03-27 Resolved 0
[2026] WAIRC 00119 WAIRC — Single Commissioner primary 2026-03-03 Against applicant 0
2026 WAIRC 00020 WAIRC — Court Session primary 2026-01-16 Against applicant 0
[2026] FWC 78 FWC primary 2026-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2026] FWC 106 FWC primary 2026-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2026] FWC 126 FWC primary 2026-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2026] FWC 97 FWC primary 2026-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2026] FWC 117 FWC primary 2026-01-01 Against applicant 0
[2026] FWC 182 FWC primary 2026-01-01 Against applicant 0