Australian Commercial Catering Pty Ltd v Powell, Marcelia & Togia, Maria

[2016] FWCFB 5467 Fair Work Commission (Full Bench) 2016-08-12

Source

Commissioner Saunders

Not yet cited by other cases

Treatment by later cases (61)

61 neutral

Citation timeline

2014

2022

2025

2026

Applicant: Australian Commercial Catering Pty Ltd

Respondent: Powell, Marcelia & Togia, Maria

This case hasn't been analysed yet.

Generate ratio, outcome, key facts, concept tags and cited-case edges. Takes ~15–30 seconds.

Authority signal

Not yet cited by other cases Signal-weighted score: 55.0

Derived from how later decisions have treated this case. Dark green = leading authority, green = positively treated, grey = neutral or sparse data, amber = caution, red = treated negatively.

Concept tags · 6

[S]Unfair dismissal (WA) [S]Unfair dismissal (federal) [S]Genuine redundancy [S]Redundancy consultation obligations [S]Reasonable redeployment in redundancy [S]Internal appeals (FB, FWCFB)

Subsequent treatment · 61

Cited / considered· 61

Cited

[2026] FWCFB 128 FWC — Full Bench — Phuong Nam (Kenny) Ha v Asuria People Services Pty Limited

Cited

[2022] FWCFB 173 FWC — Full Bench — Ready Workforce (A Division of Chandler Macleod) Pty Ltd T/A Chandler...

Cited

[2022] FWCFB 229 FWC — Full Bench — MAX Solutions T/A MAX Solutions Pty Ltd v Karla Alvarado & Thi-Quyet Nguyen

Cited

[2026] FWC 2083 FWC — Application by Redpath Contract Services Pty Ltd

Cited

[2026] FWC 1957 FWC — Application by JBS Australia Pty Limited

Cited

[2024] FWC 3157 FWC — SRG Global Integrated Services Pty Ltd v Justin Evans

Cited

[2024] FWC 2745 FWC — Job Site Recyclers Pty Ltd T/A Job Site Recyclers Pty Ltd v Zo Muan

Cited

[2024] FWC 1739 FWC — Roman Catholic Church Trust Corporation of the Archdiocese of Hobart trading...

Cited

[2024] FWC 1440 FWC — Application by Ozland Mining Services PTY LTD

Cited

[2024] FWC 1439 FWC — Application by Ozland Mining Services PTY LTD

Cited

[2024] FWC 1184 FWC — Redundancy pay Paymay Pty Ltd v Jessica Downing & Christine Reynolds

Cited

[2024] FWC 542 FWC — GS Engineering & Construction Australia Pty. Ltd. T/A GS Engineering &...

Cited

[2024] FWC 398 FWC — Watters Electrical Pty Ltd T/A Watters Electrical v Bill Harold McLaughlin

Cited

[2023] FWC 2110 FWC — Redundancy pay On The Move Caravans Pty Ltd

Cited

[2023] FWC 2100 FWC — Australian College of Optometry v Mr Ho Wah Ng

Cited

[2020] FWC 3331 FWC — Golden Glow Corporation (NT) Pty Ltd T/A Golden Glow Nursing v Mr William Dut

Cited

[2020] FWC 3330 FWC — Golden Glow Corporation (NT) Pty Ltd T/A Golden Glow Nursing v Mr Roscoe Trinidad

Cited

[2020] FWC 3328 FWC — Golden Glow Corporation (NT) Pty Ltd T/A Golden Glow Nursing v Mrs Maria Trinidad

Cited

[2020] FWC 3327 FWC — Golden Glow Corporation (NT) Pty Ltd T/A Golden Glow Nursing v Mrs Maria Cooke

Cited

[2020] FWC 3326 FWC — Golden Glow Corporation (NT) Pty Ltd T/A Golden Glow Nursing v Mrs Leisal MacDonald

Cited

[2020] FWC 3325 FWC — Golden Glow Corporation (NT) Pty Ltd T/A Golden Glow Nursing v Ms Ma Maliglig

Cited

[2020] FWC 2159 FWC — Golden Glow Corporation (NT) Pty Ltd T/A Golden Glow Nursing v Ms Kelly Gahan

Cited

[2020] FWC 582 FWC — Redundancy pay Electricity Networks Corporation T/A Western Power

Cited

[2014] FWC 2432 FWC — Funeral Industry Award 2010

Cited

[2026] FWC 60 FWC — Redundancy pay Asuria People Services Pty Limited

Cited

[2025] FWC 3812 FWC — Redundancy pay O2 Supermarket Cranbourne Pty Ltd

Cited

[2022] FWC 1815 FWC — Document: 2022FWCFB2292869788885582380

Cited

[2025] FWC 2628 FWC — The Support People Pty Ltd v Megan Poulton

Cited

[2025] FWC 2238 FWC — BGIS Pty Limited v Graham Clements-Jewery

Cited

[2025] FWC 2164 FWC — BGIS Pty Ltd Trading AS BGIS v Brendon Clarke

Cited

[2025] FWC 2160 FWC — Epichealth Pty Ltd Trading AS Epichealth Medical Clinic - Langwarrin v...

Cited

[2025] FWC 2130 FWC — Hannah's House WA Inc. Trading AS Hannah's House v Rebecca Healy

Cited

[2025] FWC 2128 FWC — Epichealth Pty Ltd Trading AS Epichealth Medical Clinic - Langwarrin v...

Cited

[2025] FWC 2119 FWC — Epichealth Pty Ltd T/A Epichealth Medical Clinic – Langwarrin v Pauline Naffaa

Cited

[2025] FWC 2050 FWC — Pohj Pty Ltd v Arvinder Singh

Cited

[2025] FWC 2049 FWC — Pohj Pty Ltd v Bavneet Kaur Sidhu

Cited

[2025] FWC 2048 FWC — Pohj Pty Ltd v Hari Prasad Kharal

Cited

[2025] FWC 2047 FWC — Pohj Pty Ltd v Mesake Turuva

Cited

[2025] FWC 1950 FWC — Epichealth Pty Ltd Trading AS Epichealth Medical Clinic - Langwarrin v Vanessa Mete

Cited

[2025] FWC 1923 FWC — Australian Footwear Pty Ltd trading as Munro Footwear Group v Raelene Risby

Cited

[2025] FWC 1814 FWC — O'Brien Group Australia Pty Ltd Trading AS O'Brien Group Australia v David Gellion

Cited

[2025] FWC 1813 FWC — Fox & Gordon Pty Ltd Trading AS Montessori Early Years Learning and Care...

Cited

[2025] FWC 1810 FWC — O'Brien Group Australia Pty Ltd Trading as O'Brien Group Australia v Michael...

Cited

[2025] FWC 1684 FWC — O'Brien Group Australia Pty Ltd Trading AS O'Brien Group Australia v Ms...

Cited

[2025] FWC 1683 FWC — O'Brien Group Australia Pty Ltd Trading as O'Brien Group Australia v Si'Alei...

Cited

[2025] FWC 1682 FWC — O'Brien Group Australia Pty Ltd Trading as O'Brien Group Australia v Rogan McGann

Cited

[2025] FWC 1632 FWC — Volunteer Centre of Western Australia Inc Trading As Volunteering WA v Tara...

Cited

[2025] FWC 1448 FWC — McNaughtans Pty Ltd v Terrance Pavitt

Cited

[2025] FWC 1130 FWC — Black Cat (Paulsens) Propriety Limited v Dean Clark

Cited

[2025] FWC 324 FWC — Queensland Police Citizens Youth Welfare Association T/A PCYC Queensland v...

Cited

[2025] FWC 193 FWC — RHC Retail Pty Ltd T/A Rook Partners Asset Management v Susan Stayt

Cited

[2025] FWC 192 FWC — RHC Retail Pty Ltd T/A Rook Partners Asset Management v Gavin Luu

Cited

[2025] FWC 191 FWC — RHC Retail Pty Ltd T/A Rook Partners Asset Management v Geordie Bunting

Cited

[2025] FWC 180 FWC — RHC Retail Pty Ltd t/as Rook Partners Asset Management v Harriet Watson

Cited

[2025] FWC 152 FWC — RHC Retail Pty Ltd T/A Rook Partners Asset Management v Diana Carr

Cited

[2026] FWC 1064 FWC — Upgrade Health Pty Ltd T/A Health First Group Gladstone v Tijesunimi Tolulope Agboola

Cited

[2026] FWC 919 FWC — Islington One Hotel Pty Ltd t/a Islington Hotel v Sam Ling

Cited

[2026] FWC 918 FWC — Islington One Hotel Pty Ltd t/a Islington Hotel v Manjot Sharma

Cited

[2026] FWC 599 FWC — Civmec Construction And Engineering Pty Ltd v Syed Muhamad Hasan Raza Rizvi

Cited

[2026] FWC 327 FWC — Uniting Church Homes Trading AS Juniper v Ms Anna Williams, Ms Manjula...

Cited

[2017] FWC 77 FWC — Application by South East Conveyors Pty Ltd

Archived text (166 words)

1 Fair Work Act 2009 s.604 - Appeal of decisions Australian Commercial Catering Pty Ltd v Marcelia Powell and Maria Togia (C2014/662) Marcelia Powell v Australian Commercial Catering Pty Ltd (C2016/3067) VICE PRESIDENT HATCHER SENIOR DEPUTY PRESIDENT O’CALLAGHAN COMMISSIONER SAUNDERS SYDNEY, 12 AUGUST 2016 Appeal against decisions [2014] FWC 2432 and [2014] FWC 2431 in matter numbers C2014/3631 and C2014/362 of Commissioner Roe at Melbourne on 10 April 2014. The Fair Work Commission orders as follows pursuant to s.120(2) of the Fair Work Act 2009: [1] The redundancy payment entitlement of Marcelia Powell under s.119 of the Fair Work Act 2009 arising from the termination of her employment with Australian Commercial Catering Pty Ltd is reduced to $3253.80. [2] The redundancy payment entitlement of Maria Togia under s.119 of the Fair Work Act 2009 arising from the termination of her employment with Australian Commercial Catering Pty Ltd is reduced to $3885.82. VICE PRESIDENT Printed by authority of the Commonwealth Government Printer <Price code A> PR584114 ORDER