WESTERN AUSTRALIAN INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION. Industrial Relations Act 1979. Mr Lloyd Edwinson and Public Service Commissioner. No. PSAB 3 of 1990. PUBLIC SERVICES GENERAL CONDITIONS OF SERVICE AND ALLOWANCES AWARD No. PSA A 4 of 1989. COMMISSIONER J. A. NEGUS. 22 February 1991. Order. HAVING heard Ms S. Young on behalf of the Applicant and Mr S. Musson on behalf of the Respondent, the Public Service Appeal Board, pursuant to the powers conferred by Section 801 of the Industrial Relations Act 1979 hereby orders — 1. That the dismissal of Mr L. Edwinson from 26 September 1990 was neither unfair nor unreasona- ble. 2. That in all the circumstances the penalty imposed on the appellant should be modified to the extent that he is to be offered a new contract of employment in an agency other than the Mines Department from 1 March 1991 at Level 1.9. 3. He is to be placed on probation and the Human Resource Manager of the agency to which he is allocated is to liaise with Mr K. Leadbetter of the Public Service Commission as to the proper management of the probationary period and the reporting requirements for confirmation of perma- nency. (Sgd.) J.A. NEGUS, [U.S.] Public Service Arbitrator, Chairperson of the Board. 71 W.A.I.G. w: PUBLIC SERVICE RECLASSIFICATION APPEALS Appeal No. Decision PSA 112/90 PSA 50/90 PSA 124/90 PSA 124/90 PSA 126/90 PSA 127/90 PSA 128/90 PSA 129/90 PSA 13/90 PSA 48/90 PSA 115/89 PSA 131/90 PSA 113/89 PSA 111/90 PSA 291/89 PSA 292/89 PSA 293/89 PSA 294/89 PSA 296/89 PSA 297/89 PSA 298/89 PSA 299/89 PSA 300/89 PSA 301/89 PSA 303/89 PSA 304/89 PSA 306/89 PSA 307/89 PSA 310/89 PSA 311/89 PSA 312/89 PSA 313/89 PSA 314/89 PSA 316/89 PSA 317/89 PSA 318/89 PSA 319/89 PSA 320/89 PSA 322/89 PSA 323/89 PSA 1/90 PSA 10/90 PSA 10/90 PSA 11/90 PSA 38/90 PSA 61/90 PSA 49/90 PSA 53/90 PSA 275/89 PSA 295/89 PSA 302/89 PSA 309/89 PSA 276/89 PSA 277/89 PSA 278/89 PSA 279/89 PSA 280/89 PSA 281/89 PSA 282/89 PSA 283/89 PSA 284/89 PSA 285/89 PSA 287/89 PSA 288/89 PSA 289/89 PSA 290/89 PSA 324/89 PSA 325/89 PSA 326/89 Conison Allan Mattie Gerard Aloysius Warber Leanne Margaret Calder Linda Winnifred Deutsch Phillipa Yolande Godfrey Judith Adriana Jacoba Pope Karen Lee Prideaux Sheridan Amanda Vadala John Graham Powell Hilary Rose West Elaine Robinson Loris Zeta Dolores Lewis Ethel June Watson Keith Beresford James Janioe Elleanor Slater Norma Marcello Deborah Jayne Tod Anny Parker Brian Edward Mawdsley Fiona Joan McKiver Garry Stephen Michel Andre Uiuam Hurdoyal Hazel Todd Hazel Dorothy VanDerSteen Paul William Mundell Kathleen Marie Earle Patrick Gerard Higgins Kenneth Robert Wells Janet McCabe Irene Bridget Owen John Andrew Dickie Patricia D'Costa Evelyn Juanite Scott Rosalind Mary Corsini Andrea Sarah Rocque Bethwynne Kay Masters Barbara Joan Ladhams Marilyn Cooney Patricia Salaman Robert Charles Parry Tracey Rosina Lang John Kimberley McKelvie John Kimberley McKelvie John Andre Taya D.K.J. Young Jill Frances Toohey John Moses Francoise Rousset Paula McFadyen Christine Gargaret Pearse Bruce Andrew Robinson June/Rose Mary Mundt Graham Key Jennifer M. Merigan Gregory Robinson Edwin James Yeomans Marie/Claire Bowald Jack Henry Jennings Maureen Ann McCarthy Lorraine Jean Cooper Patricia Carter Michele Beck Allan Edward Waters Ethel Doris Sayers Maureen Teasdale Lynne Hinchliffe Shahi Da Bandyle Steven George Mountford Albert Turner Dismissed Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn by Leave Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Dismissed Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Dismissed Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Dismissed Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn 71 W.A.I.G Effective Date* Decision 20/11/90 09/10/90 11/10/90 15/10/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 07/12/90 Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn RAILWAY RECLASSIF1CATION APPEALS Appeal Name Decision Effective No. Date* RGB 5/89 Donald George Thomas Dismissed 31/01/91 RGB 27/89 Malcolm Keith Smith Withdrawn 13/02/91 RGB 33/89 Mark James Hudson Dismissed 07/02/91 RGB 38/89 Stuart John Holmes Reclassified to Level 2 21/10/89 RGB 51/89 Ronald Keith Jennings Dismissed 07/02/91 RGB 59/89 Stanley Gordon Wyatt Withdrawn 11/02/91 RGB 61/89 Peter Daniel James Dismissed 07/02/91 RGB 68/89 Peter Bacon Withdrawn 11/02/91 RGB 70/89 Richard Glen Justins Dismissed 07/02/91 RGB 71/89 Colin David Gardiner Dismissed 07/02/91 RGB 81/89 Barry Thomas Clarke Dismissed 06/02/91 RGB 84/89 Garry Robert Newman Dismissed 05/02/91 RGB 48/89 William Kevin Maher Withdrawn 14/02/91 RGB 50/89 Gregory Power Withdrawn 14/02/91 RGB 69/89 Christopher Martin Winsor Withdrawn 14/02/91 RGB 116/89 Antonio Marchese Dismissed 29/01/91 RGB 117/89 Steven Gabrovec Dismissed 29/01/91 RGB 119/89 Vincent Joseph Omodei Dismissed 29/01/91 RGB 124/89 Nicolau Jerry Dismissed 05/02/91 RGB 127/89 Ian Raymond Harvey Dismissed 06/02/91 RGB 132/89 Christopher Meadwell Dismissed 05/02/91 RGB 133/89 Rodney Fredrick Schloithe Dismissed 31/01/91 RGB 143/89 Graham Leslie Poole Dismissed 04/02/91 RGB 144/89 John Henry Williams Dismissed 04/02/91 RGB 146/89 Colin John Miller Dismissed 04/02/91 RGB 150/89 Steven John Johnstone Dismissed 11/02/91 RGB 179/89 John Andrew Arthur Dismissed 29/01/91 RGB 198/89 Leslie John Baskerville Dismissed 29/01/91 RGB 204/89 Wayne Trevor Hill Withdrawn 14/02/91 RGB 210/89 Robert Craig Shepherd Withdrawn 11/02/91 RGB 219/89 William John O'Reilly Dismissed 06/02/91 RGB 223/89 John Joseph Rowe Withdrawn 14/02/91 RGB 229/89 Kingsley Brian Kessey Dismissed 06/02/91 RGB 230/89 Neale Maurice Fralel Dismissed 06/02/91 RGB 231/89 William Ernest Cartwright Dismissed 06/02/91 RGB 234/89 Manuel Milonas Withdrawn 14/02/91 RGB 242/89 William Murdoch McCrorie Withdrawn 11/02/91 RGB 247/89 Everard John Mercer Withdrawn 14/02/91 RGB 248/89 Clarry James Barren Dismissed 06/02/91 RGB 266/89 Justin Travis Brady Dismissed 31/01/91 RGB 271/89 Eric Raymond Youlden Dismissed 30/01/91 71 W.A.I.G. WESTERN AUSTRALIAN INDUSTRIAL GAZETTE 3 Appeal No. Decision RGB 272/89 RGB 288/89 RGB 289/89 RGB 290/89 RGB 300/89 RGB 306/89 RGB 308/89 RGB 309/89 RGB 311/89 RGB 322/89 RGB 333/89 RGB 352/89 RGB 364/89 RGB 377/89 RGB 388/89 RGB 389/89 RGB 391/89 RGB 398/89 RGB 401/89 RGB 406/89 Robert Edward G. Higgins Kenneta Leonard Brown Rodney George Barker Charles Alfred Dyson Robert Lionel Pearce Trevor Graham Burnett Angelo Daniele Barry Douglas Lloyd Richard Hamilton Enrico Valetta Thomas Ronald Keith Blinco Craig Bradley Pilton Raymond Terry McDonald David Harold Ring Emmer Michael Gill John Bona Michael E.A. Jones Robert Arthur Harris Geoffrey Grant Brook Peter Ross Turner Dismissed Dismissed Dismissed Dismissed Dismissed Dismissed Dismissed Dismissed Dismissed Reclassified to Ixvel 3 Dismissed Withdrawn Withdrawn Dismissed Dismissed Dismissed Dismissed Dismissed Withdrawn Dismissed With effect from the beginning of the first pay period commencing on or after the Effective Date. SCHOOL TEACHERS TRIBUNAL— Matters dealth with—